Sedes are Protestants. You can't be a TradCath and Sede at the same time.
2 years ago
Anonymous
Do sede churches even exist or is it just an attitude?
2 years ago
Anonymous
Sede churches exist but sometimes it's just an attitude. It's becoming more and more common. SSPV is an example of a type of Sede church. SSPX has closet Sedes but officially is anti Sede.
2 years ago
Anonymous
Most Holy Family Monastery (also stylized as MHFM) is a non-profit sedevacantist Feeneyite Catholic organization, based in Fillmore, New York. It is headed by two brothers, Brothers Michael and Peter Dimond.
According to a spokesperson for the Diocese of Buffalo the monastery is neither affiliated with the diocese nor the Roman Catholic Church.[1]
Due to its publication of a pamphlet entitled "101 Heresies of Anti-Pope John Paul II" it was declared "a dissident organization that challenges the papal authority" by the Catholic League in January 1999.[2] The group has also been condemned by the Catholic diocese of Lincoln, Nebraska.[3]
MHFM is known for their persist defense of Feeneyism and their criticism of the Catholic doctrine of baptism of desire.
2 years ago
Anonymous
It's mostly an online LARP. Even SSPX condemns sedevacantism.
2 years ago
Anonymous
SSPX officially condemns it but many of the members are closet Sedes and don't see the Pope or Vatican rules as legitimate.
2 years ago
Anonymous
2 years ago
Anonymous
>Poll from uncited website >Only 54 votes
Thanks for confirming Sedevacantism is a fringe movement with almost no followers irl. Even Jehova's Witnesses are more valid than Sedes.
2 years ago
Anonymous
Because this movement is just gaining momentum. That a poll was from a lesser known YouTube page showing SSPX are closet Sedes.
VaticanCatholic.com has 117K subscribers.
2 years ago
Anonymous
Cool, maybe they can take over in 300 years after Mormons, Muslims and the Amish already had their turn.
2 years ago
Anonymous
You're missing the point. The point is they are Israel, the chosen people, and the remnant church. 117k subscribers is a very good start and Most Holy Family Monastery has some good reviews.
2 years ago
Anonymous
>The point is they are Israel, the chosen people, and the remnant church.
Mormon missionaries told me that exact same thing literally yesterday.
2 years ago
Anonymous
what's unconvincing about these videos?
2 years ago
Anonymous
It's no less convincing than when Mormons gave me the same pitch.
Tho I got the vibe they were more committed to LARPing as Israelites.
2 years ago
Anonymous
Great, throw them on the pile of 9000 Protestant denominations in America.
2 years ago
Anonymous
When the Pope is a heretic and the Vatican are heretics, Sedevacantists are returning to the true Catholic faith. Pic related is heresy because it compares man to God.
2 years ago
Anonymous
Jehova's Witnesses and most Prots say the same thing.
Face it, you're not Catholic. You're a Prot.
2 years ago
Anonymous
>Because this movement is just gaining momentum.
Good lucking going up against the majority of the Catholic world: thirdies who don't give a frick about silly doctrinal infighting and follow mainstream Catholicism as a folk religion for the sheer reason that their forefathers were Catholic.
The women know how to traditionally dress for religious occasion while the men are lost they think they are dressing nicely for the occasion or at least traditionally but they have been mislead into wearing the satanic Masonic new world order business suit
This is the thing I don't like about Sedes. They copy paste arguments from Luther and Calvin and pass them off as their own. Your entire religion is plagiarized, Sedes haven't contributed anything of value to Christianity yet they have a massive sense of self-importance.
You do nothing but spam the same set of arguments and videos every day. You don't "argue," you just proselytize and post the copypasted drivel while never acknowledging the mountain of arguments against Sedevacantism.
Any first impressions so far?
Those are tradcaths
Check the candles
What type of personality do you sense?
Do trad catholic accept the roman catholic church as legitimate?
They can, but sedes also would consider themselves tradcaths.
Sedes are Protestants. You can't be a TradCath and Sede at the same time.
Do sede churches even exist or is it just an attitude?
Sede churches exist but sometimes it's just an attitude. It's becoming more and more common. SSPV is an example of a type of Sede church. SSPX has closet Sedes but officially is anti Sede.
Most Holy Family Monastery (also stylized as MHFM) is a non-profit sedevacantist Feeneyite Catholic organization, based in Fillmore, New York. It is headed by two brothers, Brothers Michael and Peter Dimond.
According to a spokesperson for the Diocese of Buffalo the monastery is neither affiliated with the diocese nor the Roman Catholic Church.[1]
Due to its publication of a pamphlet entitled "101 Heresies of Anti-Pope John Paul II" it was declared "a dissident organization that challenges the papal authority" by the Catholic League in January 1999.[2] The group has also been condemned by the Catholic diocese of Lincoln, Nebraska.[3]
MHFM is known for their persist defense of Feeneyism and their criticism of the Catholic doctrine of baptism of desire.
It's mostly an online LARP. Even SSPX condemns sedevacantism.
SSPX officially condemns it but many of the members are closet Sedes and don't see the Pope or Vatican rules as legitimate.
>Poll from uncited website
>Only 54 votes
Thanks for confirming Sedevacantism is a fringe movement with almost no followers irl. Even Jehova's Witnesses are more valid than Sedes.
Because this movement is just gaining momentum. That a poll was from a lesser known YouTube page showing SSPX are closet Sedes.
VaticanCatholic.com has 117K subscribers.
Cool, maybe they can take over in 300 years after Mormons, Muslims and the Amish already had their turn.
You're missing the point. The point is they are Israel, the chosen people, and the remnant church. 117k subscribers is a very good start and Most Holy Family Monastery has some good reviews.
>The point is they are Israel, the chosen people, and the remnant church.
Mormon missionaries told me that exact same thing literally yesterday.
what's unconvincing about these videos?
It's no less convincing than when Mormons gave me the same pitch.
Tho I got the vibe they were more committed to LARPing as Israelites.
Great, throw them on the pile of 9000 Protestant denominations in America.
When the Pope is a heretic and the Vatican are heretics, Sedevacantists are returning to the true Catholic faith. Pic related is heresy because it compares man to God.
Jehova's Witnesses and most Prots say the same thing.
Face it, you're not Catholic. You're a Prot.
>Because this movement is just gaining momentum.
Good lucking going up against the majority of the Catholic world: thirdies who don't give a frick about silly doctrinal infighting and follow mainstream Catholicism as a folk religion for the sheer reason that their forefathers were Catholic.
Yes. They're members of a Sedevacantist church.
They seem like happy healthy people unlike the atheists here.
me on the right
classic tradcath wear
The women know how to traditionally dress for religious occasion while the men are lost they think they are dressing nicely for the occasion or at least traditionally but they have been mislead into wearing the satanic Masonic new world order business suit
What should they be dressing like? Post a pic
This is the thing I don't like about Sedes. They copy paste arguments from Luther and Calvin and pass them off as their own. Your entire religion is plagiarized, Sedes haven't contributed anything of value to Christianity yet they have a massive sense of self-importance.
You do nothing but spam the same set of arguments and videos every day. You don't "argue," you just proselytize and post the copypasted drivel while never acknowledging the mountain of arguments against Sedevacantism.